To other writers, and your wonderful writing – thank you for these precious words

This past year, I have experienced some conflicting emotions. On one hand, I was genuinely touched by the messages that colleagues or people that I haven’t really been in touch with sent out in response to a piece of my writing. Most of these messages were truly genuine and uplifting. There were of course, for the lack of a better word, a group of people who diligently and consistently responded to almost every piece of writing that I posted online. I thanked them for their encouragement and their generosity of feedback and praise throughout the year, and in the past.

On the other hand, I was baffled and truly puzzled by a deafening silence from those that I had been, or am close to. People who are in love with words and writing and have over the years, shared via emails and WhatsApp links of articles, feature stories, musings and books that they have read and enjoyed.

It was as if, my writing (on this personal blog) and what I do for The Good Story Project, had sent them into a hole of some kind. A hole out of which no good word, or feedback critical and constructive would emerge. Their lips were sealed shut, their fingers would not press a like, or type out a word or a line to me.

Even so, I continued to compliment them. Leaving a like on their WordPress blog, and sometimes referring to the piece over a phone call. Telling them what resonated with me, what word or phrase delighted me, and what memories their retelling of an incident evoked in me. I also continued to speak to them about other people and their writing.

Then there were ‘the others’. they weren’t necessarily close friends but had been good colleagues. Journalists like me, they would often post the links to their articles on social media, including LinkedIn but they would rarely acknowledge mine.

I am still not certain what their reasons in holding out any form of feedback or dare I say praise were – was I writing too much, posting too much, were they jealous, or dismissive of what I had written or it simply did not resonate with them. I do not know.

But what I do know is this. I don’t want to dwell on that. I rather concentrate on all the good writing that exists around us, and the different kinds of writing and narratives that have resonated with me all through the year, and before that.

I want to celebrate other writers, no matter what stage of the writing journey they are at – whether they are just beginning, or are established names, or those who write without aiming or yearning for any ‘success’ of any kind. I want to celebrate their hard work, compliment them (I usually leave a comment, a like, some feedback) and most of all, I also want to share their writing with other readers. Writing is hard work. Whether you are writing a blog, news report, feature story, personal essay or a book. I don’t think I will ever hold back on complimenting – a fellow blogger, a journalist, an essayist, an author or anyone who writes – if I come across writing that reflects hard work and craft.

Of course there may be jealousy – why can’t I write like that? Or why didn’t I get to do a story like that. But over all of that is genuine admiration and joy for the people who write, and for the stories that resonate with a wide variety of people.

This post is about sharing. Sharing just a tiny bit of the writing that has meant something to me. Every day I benefit from good writing. Good writing that comes from several people across the globe. It is all around me.

So in no particular order, listing out some writing that has really resonated with me.

By John Woodrow Cox for The Washington Post. Find it here:

(It’s about three siblings. Their parents emigrated from Baghdad to US for a better life, and just when it looked like they were giving their children a better future, both die because of the coronavirus. )

A paragraph from the piece:

They never explained exactly what led them to flee Iraq, but the kids surmised that their dad’s work at a Catholic charity might have made them targets. In 2012, they moved to Michigan’s large Chaldean community, where they had no family, knew no English and lost a common last name because of a quirk in the immigration paperwork. Nameer and Nada worked hard, helping their kids earn citizenship and saving enough money by 2017 to make a small down payment on a half-century-old beige-brick ranch house in a peaceful neighborhood where people kept their yards neatly trimmed.

By Carolita Johnson for Longreads. Find it in the quote box below:

A special note about this one. I first read a piece from Carolita Johnson via my Longreads feed. Her writing spoke to me in such a manner that I went on to read all her essays. I also sought her out on Instagram, sent her a message about the impact one of her piece had on me and started following her. There have been many lines, many words and emotions from her writing that have found a place in my heart, but these ones seem to touch something that I quite can’t articulate in words.

I understood that to her, without Michael, there was no more “us,” so, logically, there was no more “ours.” She was going to separate the me from the him again. From that point I was haunted by the fear that when I came back from LA I might find all my personal effects removed. Or, in an alternative nightmare scenario, all “his” stuff would have disappeared. This isn’t a reproach against his family — if you read Joyce Carol Oates’ novel, A Widow’s Tale, this kind of paranoia, this perception of the invalidation of your existence in immediate widowhood, is normal. Nothing personal to Michael’s family.

It was just one more way I was losing my foothold on the reality I had shared with Michael. We’d closed our joint bank account when I declared bankruptcy so I could quit my job and take care of him full time, afraid it might be counted as one of my assets and used to offset my debt. If that happened we’d be left with nothing to live on while Michael recovered from surgery. I hoped my money would last until we could both start working again. But a month before he died, I’d had to tell him I couldn’t pay my half of the rent. In his stress, he had not been gracious about it. When we went grocery shopping together for the last time, I‘d been afraid to get my usual breakfast supplies and preferred to pass rather than ask him to buy them for me.

From A Woman’s Work: Becoming a Home of One’s Own

By Bhushan Korgaonkar for adda

It’s called For a daughter, a Kalpavrksha, the ever-giving tree. It’s Translated from Marathi to English by Sheela Jaywant.

A passage from the piece:

He tenderly told me that it was but a poem. ‘Who told you that it’s based on personal experience? But you cried. That means I won. Because when something that’s created from a little bit of imagination and a little bit of reality strikes someone’s heart so hard…what else can a poet want?’ He crinkled up his eyes and laughed so hard that they filled up with tears.

I was always a generous sort. My sisters were frugal and practical. Miserly, actually. Baba would tell them: ‘A well must have water drawn from it daily. Then the water that springs from below is clear, like gangajal. That’s what happens to Mohana. The more she spends, the more she earns. Still water gets stagnant. That’s what will happen to your money. Learn to spend. Be charitable. And then you’ll see how money will get drawn towards you, by itself.’

By Purusottam Thakur and Kamlesh Painkra for the People’s Archive of Rural India (PARI) website

From the story Jamlo’s last journey along a locked-down road

“She was a little girl, and walked so much [around 140 kilometres] for three days and collapsed when a distance of 55-60 kilometres more was left to reach her home,” Dr. B. R. Pujari, Chief Health and Medical Officer, Bijapur, told us on the phone. “She might have collapsed due to exhaustion and muscle fatigue, which may not figure in the postmortem report. She also fell down on the way and was injured the previous day, say the other labourers.”

By Tom Lamont for The Guardian

The invisible city: how a homeless man built a life underground

From the piece:

Good-weather months he camped on the heath, becoming familiar with the park’s night-time rhythms – first the hour the rangers knocked off, then the last of the dog-walkers, and, after that, the twilight time when the homeless presided, gathering on benches to share a beer or a spliff before they bedded down and ceded the place to the magpies and moles. There could be an absolute stillness on the heath at one or two in the morning – a stillness shredded, more than once in Van Allen’s experience, by the arrival of joyriders, convening to gun their cars over the empty grass before disappearing as suddenly as they’d come.

There are so many more. Over the past year and before that I have read so many blogs, reports, longreads and essays that have stayed with me in one way or the other. Perhaps I should do another post. Or a series of posts and link these stories up.

6 thoughts on “To other writers, and your wonderful writing – thank you for these precious words

  1. Prerna, your words resonate with me so much. I, too, am one puzzled blogger. I have often felt I understand human nature well; this is one aspect I am clueless about. There’s also the odd friend who gets upset if there’s no comment on her instagram but will resolutely avoid commenting on my blog.
    Thanks for sharing all those links. Looking forward to some good reading. And keep writing, I enjoy your work!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Jaya, I think it may be something to do with jealousy but I may be completely off the mark here. A friend told me that I seem to ignite jealousy in some of our common friends, and this blog in particular, and my writings here and on Instagram are the some of the reasons. I argued with her that those who know me, and these people do, know my journey. A little travel or rejoicing in little things and writing about them should not evoke envy. Have they not been a witness to my past, or how my mother started going blind when I was barely sixteen? She asked me to reconsider my writings. I told her, that I write because writing gives me joy. It is ‘home’ – through words and by documenting my experiences, I am building a home for myself. Plus people live far more interesting and envy inducing lives. So perhaps it may not be envy but we never know. (And thank you for reading, and writing back. I enjoy your posts too. Some of your writing takes me back to memories of my childhood, some of it makes me rejoice in the idea of India that still thrives, and most of all, all your writing comes from a place of honesty and authenticity. There is no attempt to show off – neither material things nor craft.)

      Liked by 1 person

      1. You are right, we may never know the Why of this mystery. So let’s go on writing and reading each other’s posts. Thanks for your confidence in my writing.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. People will meet your success with a variety of reactions. Some may praise you, congratulate and support you. Others, however, will try to bring you down. They give half-hearted congratulatory messages, bring up a failure in a time of a win, and ultimately seek to downplay the achievements you’ve worked so hard for. Jealous people refuse to acknowledge that it was your skills and determination that got you successful; they’d rather pass it off as dumb luck or forces beyond your control. It was because you were born in a family of means, not because you spent months hustling; or because your boss was just feeling good the day he promoted you, instead of the months of hard work you did. My advice to you, Prerna – remind yourself that it’s them and not you. If you do pause and take the time to analyze why they may be acting jealous, you can begin to understand what may be motivating their behaviours, which then makes it easier to digest the circumstance 🙂 Aiva xx Wishing peace and joy to you and your family this holiday season. Lots of love and warm hugs from Sligo

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Dear Aiva, I am going to copy the text from your comment and keep the words with me for my online journal. Your words give me much to think about, they come from such a good place that I want to go back to them in my moments of doubts and when I feel down/or let down. Thank you as always for writing in, for being so nice, honest and genuine, and wishing you a very happy Christmas and holidays too.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Great post, Prerna! And one that will resonate with many writers. It’s sometimes a lonely life. I have a possible explanation for this churlish behaviour, which I have also often experienced. It is that they simply do not like what you write, and don’t want to say so. They may not realise that some of us would rather get criticism than no feedback. I deduced this from my own behaviour once. I felt awkward to say I was really disappointed in a piece of writing someone close to me sent. And I kept wondering what to say, and in the end said nothing. Now, I make it a point to say something even if it’s just ‘Nice, but not my cup of tea’.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.